Hmm, I agree with what you said. It could rise up to 8.4x-8.5x depending on the number of excluded ratings. Bad, gives shows like Gintama a huge unfair boost, you have to watch 50+ shows of Gintama to give it a score, if you're going to watch 50 shows of something, you've got to enjoy it, so only the good ratings count. Rate my list in anime and give me some recommendations Hey I’ve recently went over my list and changed some of my scores so I’m curious to what you’ll rate my taste so here’s my mal 5 Obviously you can't compare old animation with more modern animation due to technology, but other elements are on a more leveled playing field. Honestly, rating anime (and stuffs in general) felt quite a bit like putting a book-end-thingy. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. In a reply to the post, MyAnimeList noted that spam accounts are counted in the ranking, but that Attack on … how do you rate old anime (80's, 90's, early 2000's) that was very original or outstanding when it came out but its tropes/story/plot point/character archetypes etc. What do you think of MAL's 10 number rating scale? Support And productionwise I don't think they were inferior, quite the opposite, older styles are often really charming. … Explore myanimelist search your favorite manga/anime. Anime can refer either to animated films or TV series, furthering the confusion. The logical fallacy that construct such reasoning itself. (Topic ID: 1842781) 144,668 users listed the anime as 'watching' as of Monday. People wonders. so you'd have to at least watch 20 episodes before you rate it. I’m pretty new to anime and MAL and I’m kind of confused about the rating system. You'll need to watch 2.4 rounded to 2 episodes for a 12-episode anime and 4.8 rounded to 5 episodes for a 24-episode anime. Pretty sure the R2 ending influenced all the 10s its getting. same as I rate anything, enjoyment plus production values plus originality plus how it compares to other works of the same genre. I tend to dislike the idea that a story (or story trait) can be "overplayed over time" or lose its value simply based on when it was released. It's just not worth the effort IMO. is a property of MyAnimeList Co.,Ltd. What do you guys think of the rating system? became really overplayed over time to the point that if that anime would come out today, it would be considered a mediocre show at best? 3. Update your anime/manga progress. Your argument is fine and valid, but it doesn't work as cleanly as that. Do Not Sell My Personal Information Track yout anime/manga progress. But that probably didn't have any effect to the actual ratings so it is just a visual flaw and not a functional one. I rate based only on personal enjoyment, so the age of an anime isn't really a factor for me. See characters, videos. ", Alot of people just rate it off of the common 1 being a sour flavor of bullshit, while 10, in their opinion, is the greatest thing to have ever been thought up while on questionable narcotics. In the end, each way has it's pros and cons, and it's not exactly clear which way is going to give the most "accurate" results. Well that depends, most of the older anime I loved still seem very original for me and they're nothing like any other shows that came after them (for example Ashita no Joe, Cowboy Bebop, Perfect Blue, Macross, Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu etc). See your profile and anime stats. And all that left was only sound and fury of the past. Outstanding to mediocre? When you finish a show, the hardest part comes down to "What should I rate it? I don't like MAL's rating system, largely because I consider my 10/10s to be my current absolute favorite shows and 1/10 is the worst show I've ever seen. Who cares if it was a novel concept or tropes for the time if it's the worst version of those features? I use every rating, though, so the scale just needs a bit more precision and it's perfect enough :). I think the anime's rating will go rise in numbers once it finishes airing if those that rated it with low numbers drop it. Characters like Ippo Makunouchi from shows like Hajime no Ippo stand out compared to most shonen protagonists today because of the fact that he was a character that started of timid, shy, and lacking self-confidence in his own physical capabilities. This anime probably is on par with SAO in terms of mixed reactions. Bragging rights (for studios who create the anime). More slack will be given to animation/art style (while it isn't that old, clannad's art style is godawful but that's not even remotely the biggest problem with the series, for instance, and it counts almost nothing to the final score) but if characters/story suck balls (or a lame trope is repeated ad nauseam) then they suck, no slack given there. Browse Top anime/manga, Seasonal, Currently airing and more! I'm the type of guy who will rate cardboard cutouts on a stick with a 10/10 if the story justifies it. There is no perfect solution and MAL ratings will never be more than a rough estimate of what most people like. I think they should either just come up with a definitive number like 4 episodes in is when scores count or replace it with 20% up until 12 episodes which is the upper limit. That's one more hour of eating your vomit. Read reviews in app When I rate an older anime, the only thing I do is turn a blind eye to things like animation and sound quality. I don’t really see why anyone would rate old and new anime differently unless talking about the production. Terms NSFW filter available. This means that my most given ratings are 6s and 7s even though technically that should be a 5. Explore myanimelist search your favorite manga/anime. Track yout anime/manga progress. These are actually known as "manga," though many anime series are … Anime Schedule. Do you rate it like it says with 10 being masterpiece 5 being average and 0 being appalling? Otherwise I rate it completely the same way based on how I enjoyed the show. "I should reward myself by giving it a 10 / 1 / 5". Refine See titles to watch instantly, titles you haven't rated, etc Instant Watch Options By giving half or decimal point ratings it makes the score less useful to a new viewer. I'm happy enough with assigning a rating to something for the purposes of my own list, I don't need to know that it 'counts' for the averaged ratings on each anime's page or the general top anime list. Or in extremely rare cases a worthy successor. MyAnimeList allows users to score the anime and manga on their list on a scale from 1 to 10. I have a bunch of 9.5's for example that now have to be either 9 or 10. Your opinion won't change it. It is currently the lowest-rated harem anime on MyAnimeList with a rating of 4.42 based on 12,716 users' scores. I'd say I would just rate it based on that. So you have a scale within a scale. This anime probably is on par with SAO in terms of mixed reactions. Metaphor means watching an anime you consider to be shit just to be able to make your rating count. My rating won't change. Now what about those who dropped it around episode 19? Based on enjoyment like modern anime. NSFW filter available. Now what about those who dropped it around episode 19? A two-episode OVA, each episode of Eiken is 30 minutes, using elements of comedy, ecchi, harem, and school anime. Personally, I think MAL's rating system is good yet flawed. If you feel like you're "eating your vomit" watching a show, chances are most people would give it a 1 or something extremely low and drop it, which would skew a lot of shows. The 1/5 rule only applies to shows that have finished airing. Welp, thanks for reminding me of short anime because I really forgot about that when I made my post. Fairy Tail iirc has 100+ episodes(?) From ghosts to mystical creatures, here are 10 of the best supernatural manga, according to MyAnimeList. So you can't really ask someone else to rate your anime tastes)) 2020-06-19 16:42 #82. At least 25%, because if you drop a show at episode 1-3 (for one cour shows) you often can't accurately judge it. What's more, animation quality is not high on my list of criteria, story and characters are. Should it be lowered or is it fine as is? is an extension of your profile, showing you various stats about your anime and manga. It's not their fault that a show can't hook you within the first or second episode. I rate them based purely on enojyment, just like any other anime. For seasonal anime, it definitely needs to be higher. Pokémon: Top 10 Fan-Favorite Characters (According To MyAnimeList) Anime with popular mascots are often the series that become the most popular, but Pokémon benefits from its roster of memorable characters. Hate. Especially character designs. Mostly just with the same standards as modern anime, but when it comes to animation and production values I'll be a bit more forgiving. See characters, videos. When people see out of 10, they just relate that to the percentage/school system because it is the most familiar and that is what they vote by changing actual votes to be out of 4 or 5 wouldn't change much because people would just do the same thing but with less precision. 2 episodes is fine, but with a 24-episode anime it already rose up by 3. Obviously you can't compare old animation with more modern animation due to technology. The system is obviously flawed and favors long shows, but removing or lowering it would make it even worse for seasonal anime. Update your anime/manga progress. Wait, before you say "then those who dropped it at episode 1 would make the anime's ratings too low", please don't. Brimmed with anger but subdued. Highest-Rated Anime Series on IMDb by smcgann14 | created - 13 Feb 2016 | updated - 01 Mar 2017 | Public Must have 5,000 votes or higher and a score above 7.5 to qualify. MAL Steam Club . There's no way to even tell that someone watched any of the show, so I think this is the best were gonna get. ©2021 All Rights Reserved. Little did they know, all this is nurturing a masochistic tendencies towards the reason behind those numbers. Notice at Collection I feel they peaked with Mikimoto and Sadamoto. Sitemap. This is a public club. Anime Schedule. The distinction for me is usually whether or not the first half/season was written with the knowledge that there would be a second. I prefer 100 rating scales, too many of my shows are definitively better than others in the same score bracket. It is not a shame to rate the 70s Little Prince higher than Kino No Tabi ,you know. Life goes on. I don't go to that list to have my opinions validated or to find new things to watch. I'm not saying MAL should drop the minimum episodes watched into 0%, I'm saying it should at least be lowered to around 10%. Animation, artstyle and OST are the least important aspects in my book, so the fact that they are less good in the older ones doesn't change a thing for me. Yes, I know that finishing shit anime is bad, but there are a lot of people like me who finish shit anime just for the heck of it. VIEW ALL. This pretty much, since out of almost 7500 shows rated in mal, 98.3% of them have over 5 points and well, pretty much only 10 animes have over 9 points so there is your scale from 5-9 i guess, Using 20% episodes watched for your rating to count is really too high of a percentage to use especially with long running anime like One Piece [...]. so you'd have to at least watch 20 episodes before you rate it. Advertising ... You can rate & review any titile, search voice actors (foriegn & domestic) by name or show. Just project the score mal gives you onto your own scale. We cannot go back in time or emulate what it was like back then, or compartmentalize the decades of anime to accurately represent it's era. No matter what you do you can't be representative of everyone and you could make a convincing argument for only calculating ratings that list a show as completed. If a show did not age well its just a bad show. But hey. I agree with your whole point that shows that are bad get a very large boost because of people giving it a bad rating and dropping it, but I don't think you can truly give a thorough and critical rating until you've seen the whole show. They probably won't drop it and watch it since they already finished the prequel so I'm talking about those who rated it even though they didn't watch it. How good it would be today. NEXT: Best Harem Anime (According to MyAnimeList) Like any other show? I understand your reasons, but I personally don't even think you should be able to truly score a show until you've watched the whole thing. Browse Top anime/manga, Seasonal, Currently airing and more! Honestly 20% feels kind of short. suicide | ... and some people also have a different idea of what rates are for them. became really overplayed over time to the point that if that anime would come out today, it would be considered a mediocre show at best? But if I watch something older and think "I've already seen this in some new shows" then it all depends on the execution. RATE MYANIMELIST. At the time you reach 20% of the episodes of an anime like Fairy Tail, you probably already like it so much. Let's face it, even if someone supposedly watched 100% of an anime there is no way to check that. In the second case, I probably won't enjoy the old one very much and I won't be giving it any extra points jus for being old (that's why I dropped Slam Dunk). An enigma. I swear I've seen a lot of low reviews for some mainstream airing anime and I'm a bit surprised Fairy Tail has a high rating for something that gets hated a lot more than the normal. And honestly, it doesn't even matter. Besides, if it stands the test of time, that's how classics are recognized. One Piece episode 914 & 915 were a mistake. How much do you weight this in your rating. Its a clear 4 point scale for a majority of users. I'd rate it the same way as I would a 2020 seasonal. Explore myanimelist search your favorite manga/anime. Anime Schedule. One Piece is still airing and the total episode count is unknown, so right now every rating counts. Internalizing all your experiences and enjoyment/disappointment then abstracting them to a single number seems to entice the mind of the masses and tingles their sensitive spots in the brain. Then every other anime copying its formula, will either be mediocre. People have been writing stories fo rmillennia, no excuse for poor ones. if not, oh well. Right now the top 100 anime is full of shows between 8.xx to 8.xx. Basically the same as the modern ones. Update your anime/manga progress. To be honest the biggest problem I see with the way things are rated on MAL -- and it might be an insoluble one -- isn't the proportion you need to see to have your rating 'count' but the phenomenon where sequels have substantially inflated ratings because most of the people who watch and rate them are people who bought into the show in the first place. Do you think watching 20% of the anime for your rating to count is good? 10 Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun - 8.63 Fairy Tail iirc has 100+ episodes(?) Can you provide examples? If you use the 4 star system and it worked out effectively then awesome. Sometimes the older anime is still superior or at least on par, but sometimes it's inferior and I feel like some newer anime already did it better. (Anime is often incorrectly used to refer to Japanese comic books as well. The ultimate anime and manga database MyAnimeList allows users to rate every show and collectively determine the top-rated anime movies on this list. It's otherwise fine, but I could do with .5 ratings since I watch a lot more good shows that I watch bad ones. the distinction between 'separate sequel' and 'the second half of the same thing' is super-hazy at best. About I just see when it was released to get an idea of what was the thing going on during those times and later if the story is good or not. Despite being one of the lowest-rated in vampire anime, there are some people who rate this short highly. The lowest-rated anime on MyAnimeList, the worst fruit in this bag of rotten apples, featuring every bad idea ever incorporated into anime and combining it to deliver an experience that is simply too overwhelming to explain in words is Abunai Sisters: Koko & Mika. Browse Top anime/manga, Seasonal, Currently airing and more! I haven't watched that many old anime, but plotwise, I haven't seen an anime from the previous century than can compare to a modern anime. I don't understand the question. I really want this but apparently, the site's owners think this type of feature suggestion will cause problems by people who want more and more precision which I don't really agree with. No. RELATED: 10 Worst Supernatural Anime, Ranked According To MyAnimeList. These scores are then aggregated to give each show in the database a rank from best to worst. It would also be pretty hard to find shows like that as people rarely talk about random shitty shows for no reason and if I managed to find garbage like that, I'd probably drop it in an episode and not even put it in my mal. always taking into consideration the time it was released, hence can't be dismissive about what existed back in the day that is not compatible with today's standards. If you drop the percentage then shows which have a slower/worse first few episodes, but make up for it in the back half are at a disadvantage. A show's rank is calculated twice a day using the following formula: R=vS+mCv+m{\displaystyle R={\frac {vS+mC}{v+m}}} I'm pretty sure lots of anime ratings would go down if the minimum episodes you need to watch gets lessened.